Library Technology Guides

Document Repository

Customer support ratios

Library Systems Newsletter [July 1996]

Image for Customer support ratios

One of the most important criteria for evaluating vendors of automated library systems is customer support: the support which a vendor provides after the contract is signed and includes system installation, implementation, and ongoing maintenance. An objective tool for measuring such support is the customer support ratio: the ratio between the number of support staff and the number of installed systems. The following ratios have been calculated using data supplied to LSN by vendors for the Annual International Survey of Multiuser Integrated Library Systems which was published in the combined March and April issues:


RankingVendorRatio
1. Endeavor 1:0.64
2. CARL 1:2.25
3. Keystone Systems 1:2.5
4. Geac 1:3.21
5. PICA 1:4.37
6. C0BIT 1:4.5
7. Maxcess 1:5
7. Pacific Automated Library System 1:5
9. BLCMP 1:5.83
10. Advanced Computer Concepts1:6
10. Contec Data 1:6
12. Innovative Interfaces 1:6.62
13. Gaylord 1:6.8
14. Ameritech 1:7.4
15. LGB & Associates 1:7.66
16. Best Seller 1:10.57
17. Sirsi 1:10.58
18. VTLS 1:11.09
19. Fretwell-Downing 1:12.36
20. Stowe Computing 1:13.12
21. DRA 1:14.87
22. NSC 1:15.33
23. Georgetown University 1:17.5
24. Gateway 1:19
25. Ex Libris 1:21
26. Information Dimensions 1:36.71
27. OPSYS 1:38.22
28. Siemens 1:44.75

All other vendors which provided data had more than 50 sites per customer support staff. (1:50+)

All ratios of 1:10 or better are considered to be excellent and it would be inappropriate to conclude that a ratio of 1:2.25 (CARL) is substantially better than a ratio of 1:7.4 (Ameritech) without looking at the nature of the customer base. (The former customer base consists of a small number of large systems, while the latter consists of systems of all sizes.) Also, in the case of Endeavor, the customer base during 1995 was so small that the calculated ratio is skewed. The larger, more complex accounts may require more support. However, as the ratio expands beyond 1:10, there is reason to contact customers to determine if there are any deficiencies in support. The author recently did so in the case of DRA, which has a ratio of 1:14, and learned that customer support was deemed to be very good or excellent by all of the institu-tions contacted.

We seriously doubt that customer support can be anything but minimal if the ratio is 1:20 or greater. As to the vendors with ratios of 1:50 or greater, its difficult to imagine what kind of service they can be providing.

Permalink:  
View Citation
Publication Year:1996
Type of Material:Article
Language English
Published in: Library Systems Newsletter
Publication Info:Volume 16 Number 07
Issue:July 1996
Page(s):53-54
Publisher:American Library Association
Place of Publication:Chicago, IL
Notes:Howard S. White, Editor-in-Chief; Richard W. Boss, Contributing Editor
Company: Endeavor Information Systems, Inc.
CARL Corporation
Keystone Systems, Inc.
Geac
CoBIT
Maxcess Library Systems, Inc.
Pacific Automated Library Systems, Inc.
BLCMP Library Services
Advanced Computer Concepts
Contec Data Systems
Innovative Interfaces, Inc.
Gaylord Information Systems
Ameritech Library Services
LGB & Associates, Inc.
Best-Seller Library Systems, Inc.
SIRSI Corporation
VTLS, Inc.
Fretwell-Downing Informatics
Stowe Computing Australia
Data Research Associates, Inc.
NSC, Inc.
Georgetown University
Gateway Software Corporation
Ex Libris
Information Dimensions, Inc.
OPSYS
Siemens Nixdorf Informationssysteme
GIS Information Systems
Subject: Library automation vendors -- customer support
ISSN:0277-0288
Record Number:7148
Last Update:2022-08-06 20:37:40
Date Created:0000-00-00 00:00:00
Views:46